Better spaces for older people
17 December 2010
Urban planning needs to consider how older people use walking routes as well as public areas, concludes a Research Council UK-funded research project from the New Dynamics of Ageing Programme. Planning should include a smooth transition between walking, driving and using public transport and should take account of how older people navigate between these.
The research project 'Older People's Use of Unfamiliar Space' (OPUS) examined the strategies used by older people to find their way in unfamiliar spaces as pedestrians and users of public transport. As part of the research, older people were shown town scenes and pedestrian routes and gave feedback on signposting, ease of navigation and general impressions. Their heart rates were measured to monitor stress levels. Participants were also taken to a town centre to walk through the same routes in person.
Initial findings show:
- Signs are of limited use even in unfamiliar new areas – they were often positioned incorrectly or too high, and
- Designing outdoor spaces that are more easily navigable and walkable are important in making the environment less stressful and anxiety-inducing;
- Buildings and landmarks are particularly important as navigational aids, especially churches.
The research project also conducted interviews with spatial planners to examine how older people were included in the planning process. The responses indicated that older people are being increasingly engaged, not least through the Equality Impact Assessment where older people are represented as an important group. Planners considered that older people today have greater political awareness and power and were able to collaborate with the process. Efforts are currently made to make public spaces 'older person-friendly' as part of lifetime places guidelines - for instance the location and number of bus shelters, seating and public toilets. Older people’s needs are also considered in relation to housing issues, such as location, neighbourhood considerations and land use requirements for special housing, and mechanisms to encourage older people to downsize.
However, the diversity of older people and their different needs are not fully recognised. Planning focus has tended to be on combating particular issues such as youth crime and problem drinking, or the mobility needs of elderly people. There is still a need to understand older people's various requirements in their use of space, reflecting their diversity and different backgrounds. While some are experienced travellers who are used to finding their way in unfamiliar spaces, others may suffer cognitive impairment which makes previously familiar areas unrecognisable and means they need different cues in their environment. Treating 'age' as a single category can therefore be unhelpful for planners in designing urban spaces, concludes the research.
"Older people are increasingly experiencing unfamiliar places through travel. Creating spaces that make the urban environment more friendly and pleasant will be ever more important to enable older people to remain independent," comments lead researcher Professor Judith Phillips. "The OPUS findings have significance for planners in redesigning town centres, allowing them to develop inclusive environments that have meaning for older people."
For further information contact
- Professor Judith Phillips
Telephone: 01792 602341
ESRC Press Office:
- Danielle Moore
Telephone: 01793 413122
- Jeanine Woolley
Telephone: 01793 413119
Notes for editors
- The project, Older People's Use of Unfamiliar Space was carried out by lead researcher Professor Judith Phillips, Centre for Innovative Ageing, Swansea University, and co-investigators, Professor Nigel Walford, Kingston University, Dr Michael Lewis, Swansea University, Professor Nigel Foreman, Middlesex University and Ms Ann Hockey, Anglia Ruskin University.
- This project is part of the New Dynamics of Ageing Programme which is a seven year multidisciplinary research initiative with the ultimate aim of improving quality of life of older people. The programme is a collaboration between five UK Research Councils, led by the ESRC, and includes EPSRC, BBSRC, MRC, ESRC and AHRC.
- Forty four older people (18 males, 26 females) were shown films of unfamiliar and familiar town and city spaces and pedestrian routes in a 'virtual reality cave', where they navigated a route in an unfamiliar area. They assessed use of signage, cues for finding the way and general impression of the route, and stress levels were monitored through heart rate readings. A survey and qualitative interview explored issues connected to unfamiliar environments. A group of ten participants were taken to an unfamiliar town centre to follow the route projected in
- Research Councils UK (RCUK) is the strategic partnership of the UK's seven Research Councils. We invest annually around £3 billion in research. Our focus is on excellence with impact. We nurture the highest quality research, as judged by international peer review, providing the UK with a competitive advantage. Global research requires we that sustain a diversity of funding approaches, fostering international collaborations, and providing access to the best facilities and infrastructure, and locating skilled researchers in stimulating environments. Our research achieves impact - the demonstrable contribution to society and the economy made by knowledge and skilled people. To deliver impact, researchers and businesses need to engage and collaborate with the public, business, government and charitable organisations.